You can be given a title. Authority is something other people decide to give you.
Nurses, physios, doctors, community leads and administrators keep finding the same gap between the title they hold and the authority they actually have. This episode goes back to Chester Barnard, who argued in 1938 that authority belongs to the person receiving an instruction, not the one giving it, and asks what his “zone of indifference” means for anyone who has just been promoted.
Further reading
- The Functions of the Executive, Chester I. Barnard (1938). Where the episode starts. Barnard ran New Jersey Bell, and his chapter on the theory of authority is worth the effort on its own.
- Administrative Behavior, Herbert A. Simon (1947). Simon reworked Barnard’s zone of indifference as the “zone of acceptance”, and shows how the idea holds up under closer scrutiny.
- The Bases of Social Power, John R. P. French and Bertram Raven (1959). The classic split between authority that comes with the job and authority that comes from what you know and who trusts you.
- Leadership Without Easy Answers, Ronald A. Heifetz (1994). Draws a hard line between authority and leadership, and argues that some of the most important leadership comes from people without the title.
Michael’s book The Next Station Is… is available on Amazon.